MONDAY, SECOND WEEK OF LENT
Dn 9: 4-10 Ps 79: 8-9, 11, 13 Lk 6: 36-38
JUDGE NOT, BUT DISCERN
The verse “Judge not, lest you be judged” is often misconstrued as an absolute prohibition against forming opinions or assessments of others. This interpretation, however, overlooks the nuanced and multifaceted nature of judgment, which calls for discernment and the ability to distinguish between truth and error, good and evil.
- Mt 7:15-16 warns us to be wary of false prophets. How can we identify them if we are forbidden from evaluating their teachings and the fruits of their ministry?
- 1 Jn 4:1-2 instructs Christians to “test the spirits” to determine whether they are from God.
- Lk 12:57 praises those who demonstrate wisdom and discernment in their understanding of others.
- Jn 7:24 explicitly commands us to judge others, not based on superficial appearances, but with righteous judgment.
These passages demonstrate that while indiscriminate and harsh judgment is to be avoided, a discerning and Christ centered evaluation of others is not only permissible but also essential for Christian growth and discipleship.
Thus, Scripture abounds with instructions on the Christian’s duty to discern truth from error and right from wrong. This necessitates making judgments about the world around us. What then are we to make of this statement of Christ about not judging? This apparent paradox highlights a crucial aspect of Christian discipleship: the distinction between condemnation and discernment. While condemnation involves harsh, self righteous judgment, often motivated by pride or a desire for superiority; Discernment, on the other hand, is a Christ centred evaluation, rooted in love and guided by the Holy Spirit. It involves recognizing sin in ourselves and others while extending grace and offering opportunities for repentance.
Response: O Lord, do not treat us according to our sins.
Copyright ©2025 ©Springs of Living Water http://springs.carmelmedia.in